Is your drummer useful or dead weight? (16/1/2009)
By: dragonglobe
Is
your drummer useful or just dead weight? The effectiveness of the drummer
varies greatly from team to team. Some want the smallest lightest body
possible, while others see this as a critical and strategic part of the crew.
Some teams rely heavily on the drum beat while others ignore it.
The
deceitful drum impact “I did not want to believe it and therefore I checked it
once. Does the speed of the sound really have a negative effect on the
uniformity of the stroke rate within a Dragon Boat or can you rely on the drum
beat to set the stroke rate?
At
a temperature of 18°C the speed of sound amounts to approx. 342 meters per
second. The sound needs only approx. 0.03 seconds to travel the ten meters from
the Drummer to the last paddling bench. With a frequency of 60 strokes per
minute a paddle stroke takes one second and the hand of the Paddlers moves in
this time approx. one meter. In 0.03 seconds the paddle moves thus 0.03 m = 3
cm. Related to the overall length of the paddle stroke a delay of 3% results.
If one considers that over 10 paddling benches the total could be 30 cm the
delay rises to nearly 10%. If you can believe in these numbers then the
situation is what we always knew it to be – that the drum beat is only a
paddling Rhythm. The question then arises: “Why do we need the Drummer?” - Very
simply, because a Dragon Boat without Drummer is no longer a Dragon Boat and
because we do need someone to throw into water after Racing and - finally we
all want our fun!”
Mathematically
the article may be right about the Drum Impact; but only mathematically. Most
drummers can only be heard by the front half of the boat. The back half uses a
variety of means to keep time including the most common method of watching the
lead strokes. In many boats the helm will help relay communications to the back
half. By working together the helm and the drummer form a team that ensures
complete communication within the boat. Some of these teams use elaborate
signals and code words to keep their crew informed, while keeping the
competition in the dark.
Calling
the finish or a rate up or a power sequence are all critical elements of a race
and the paddlers all need this information simultaneously. Some teams overcome
this with the use of electronics. The “cox-vox” is a system that amplifies a
voice and projects it over three speakers in the boat. All paddlers are getting
the information at the same time. My experience in international events shows
that the microphone is used equally in the front and the back of the boat
depending on where the team leader is located.
Don’t
discount the steersperson when making your decision about the drummer. A good
helm can read a race and is in a better position to see what is happening with
the competition. Additionally, the helm is not occupied with the beating of the
drum and trying to hang on to a tiny seat swaying in the wind. Regardless of
whether or not your drummer is the key part of your team or just along for the ride,
there is something to be said about the position. A drummer sitting tall
beating the drum with vigour and rhythm is a beautiful sight and an integral
part of the sport. The boom, boom, boom of the drums echoing across the water
help differentiate our sport from all others and I wouldn’t have it any other
way. If he or she has a loud voice that helps motivate the paddlers and carry
the team to victory, all the better. Does a 3% lag mean so much that we should
discount one of the cornerstones of the sport? Not in my opinion. Although I
may disagree with the article I have to agree with one aspect. It is fun to
take the person who has been yelling at you during all the practices and races
and throw them into the water.